Subtraction with manipulatives — how to do it

Subtraction is harder than addition. Why, how to avoid pitfalls and why negatives come later in the journey.

5 min read·Ages 5-7·2026-10-22

They handle 4 + 3 = 7 without trouble. But 7 - 3 = ? They pause. Think. Count fingers. Subtraction is harder than addition. Not because it's more complex on paper — but because the brain loves to add and struggles to subtract.

This article shows why subtraction is harder, how to train it with manipulatives, and why negative numbers come much later. At Kluriko there are subtraction games in the Learning Games — but at home with beads and pasta the understanding builds deeper.

Why is subtraction harder?

1. One direction only. 4+3 = 3+4. Both work. But 7-3 ≠ 3-7. They must remember which number is before minus.

2. Counting backwards. "7, 6, 5, 4" is harder than "7, 8, 9, 10". Many 6-year-olds can't do backwards counting.

3. Mental motion. Addition is building together. Subtraction is pulling apart. The latter is more abstract.

4. Negatives loom. "5 - 8 = ?" doesn't exist in the ordinary world. They don't know what it means.

When to start?

Age 5: simple "take away" tasks concretely. "You have 5 apples. I eat 2. How many left?"

Age 6: subtraction with material up to 10.

Age 7: abstract subtraction under 10. "7 - 3 = 4."

Age 8: subtraction up to 20. With strategy.

Age 9: 2-digit subtraction. Written method.

They need secure addition before starting subtraction.

Step 1: Concrete material

Take-away game

"You have 8 beads. I take 3. How many left?" They physically remove, count the rest.

This is subtraction-foundation. Nothing else.

Where's-the-rest game

"You had 10 sweets. You gave 4 to your sister. How many left?" They see physically the rest is 6.

Bead-string trick

Use a counting string with 10 beads. They slide 4 to the left. "How many on the right?" 6.

Shows number bonds and subtraction at the same time.

Step 2: Pictorial

Picture subtraction

Draw 8 apples. Cross out 3. "How many left?" They count.

Number line

Write 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10. They point at 8, jump 3 steps back. "Where are they?" 5.

Precursor to 100-grid subtraction.

Step 3: Abstract

Subtraction tables

They learn systematically:

  • 1-0, 1-1
  • 2-0, 2-1, 2-2
  • 3-0, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3
  • ... up to 10-10

Massive. But gradual. Not all at once.

Three strategies

Count backwards. "8-3 = 8, 7, 6, 5. Answer: 5."

Use number bonds. "10-4 = ?" They know 4+6=10, so 10-4=6.

Think addition. "7-3 = ?" They think "3 + ? = 7". 3+4=7. Answer: 4.

The last strategy is the adult version. Adults treat subtraction as "missing addend". They learn this at 8-9.

Subtraction with "borrowing from ten"

At 7-8 they learn subtraction over 10:

13 - 7 = ?

Strategy 1: count back. 13, 12, 11, 10, 9, 8, 7, 6. Answer: 6. Slow.

Strategy 2: use 10. "13 = 10 + 3. 10 - 7 = 3. 3 + 3 = 6." Fast.

What teachers teach in year 2. Number bonds to 10 are central.

Negatives — wait!

They ask: "What's 4 - 8?"

They can answer "can't be done". OK. Correct at primary level.

Negatives are introduced in middle school (years 4-6). And it's OK for a 7-year-old not to grasp them yet.

Common problems

They flip subtraction. "8-3" becomes "3-8" in their head. Show concretely: "8 is more. We start with 8."

They include the start number when counting. "8-3 = 8, 7, 6 = 6." Wrong. Count back 3 steps from 8: 7, 6, 5. Answer 5.

They lose patience. Subtraction frustrates. Stop. Return to concrete material.

They guess. They blurt a number, hope it's right. Solution: back to concrete material, they should see the answer.

Subtraction games

Race game

They start with 20 sticks. Each die roll removes that many sticks. Get to 0. Trains subtraction.

Money game

They have 50 kr. They "buy" things at different prices. Subtract each purchase. They see subtraction in daily life.

Snap-back

Stick 10 notes on the wall. They remove one at a time, say how many left. 10-1=9, 9-1=8...

Written subtraction

At 9-10 they learn long subtraction: 235 - 178. This uses:

  • Base ten
  • Borrow from next column
  • Written form

Preparation: all prior steps. Concrete material, number bonds, addition. No skipping.

How Kluriko helps

Kluriko Learning Games have subtraction games that start with visual representation and build to abstract. Continuous training across all levels.

Explore more on Kluriko

Read next